Posted by Margaret Daisley
I’ve been hearing the grumblings for some time now, mostly from marketing folks. The broad topic of the grumblings had to do with the burden of surveys they were expected to fill out. It wasn’t so much the fact-based surveys like The Am Law 200 and The NLJ 250 which lead to adjectives such as “biggest” and “richest.” Or the associate satisfaction surveys (The Midlevel Associate Survey and The Summer Associate Survey), in which ephemeral attributes such as “most satisfied” can be measured on a 5-point scale.
No, it was the beauty contests that were causing the problems, these marketing folks would say. Beauty contests are those surveys in which the firm or individual lawyer (read: marketing staff member) must fill out endless forms and complete (or arrange to complete) endless interviews about one’s self and other “best” and “super” lawyers and law firms and law departments. Unlike surveys which use mostly quantitative measurements, beauty contests use more qualitative methodology. As described in a recent blog post by consultant Larry Bodine on his Law Marketing Portal: “The publisher of Super Lawyers, Minneapolis-based publisher Law & Politics, a division of Key Professional Media … conducts surveys to identify the best 5% of all lawyers in a state, based on their verdicts, settlements, transactions, clients, experience, honors, position in the firm and pro bono work.” And “The Best Lawyers in America, published biennially since 1983, is a lawyer referral guide covering 57 specialties in the U.S.
(Full disclosure: As ALM editor in chief Monica Bay puts it on her blog, The Common Scold, our mutual employer, ALM Media Inc., partners with Best Lawyers to produce "The New York Area's Best Lawyers," which runs as a Special Advertising Supplement in New York magazine.)
The lists are compiled through a peer-review survey in which lawyers confidentially evaluate their professional peers. The 2006 edition of Best Lawyers, is based on more than 1.5 million evaluations of lawyers by other lawyers.”
Recent Comments